The murder victim of choice in this book is Katie Steelock, a minor TV celebrity, who unsurprisingly has numerous admirers and detractors. She meets her demise after leaving a tennis club party early, presumably to meet her killer by a nearby boat house. Due to her social connections her case is quickly taken up by Scotland Yard, in particular Chief Superintendent Knott, who is keen to make a conviction in order to gain a promotion. Yet he works with several local policemen as well. His desired quick conviction seems almost a given when they come across their prime suspect, Jonathan Limbery, who far from helps his cause, even if he is innocent. On the opening pages he seems like a nice person, but very rapidly this veneer disappears – yet despite his unpleasant persona did he do the deed? Not everyone is quite so sure.
Overall Thoughts
Although this is an updated village mystery, there are still a large number of characters to take on board in the opening pages. Yet in the main most do not need to be remembered, as the reader never really gets close to any of them and to that end I couldn’t really get into any of the characters – the 80s mystery milieu probably didn’t help this. Though this is a book with a number of surprising twists and turns, with an unexpected ending which is fully prepared for, revealing Gilbert’s strength in plotting. Despite this though this tale struggled to keep my attention, the police procedural aspect might not have worked for me so well, which is a shame as I have enjoyed earlier Michael Gilbert novels such as Death Has Deeps Roots (1951) and The Danger Within (1952).
Rating: 3.25/5
Just the Facts Ma’am (Silver Card): Set in a small village
John at Pretty Sinister seems to have had a better time with this book, so do read his review.
Like you, I enjoyed Michael Gilbert’s early mysteries more than his later ones.
LikeLike
I always love to see a review of books by Michael Gilbert as I am wanting to read through all of his books, if possible. I also read your review of Death Has Deep Roots, and I saw you did not care for the Calder and Behrens book of stories. I loved those stories, but spy fiction is one of my favorite sub-genres.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Given your greater love for 60-80s mystery fiction and the police procedurals I think you’ll really enjoy this one.
LikeLike
I am sorry that this book, possibly my favorite Gilbert novel, did not resonate with you. The “police procedural” element is indeed very pronounced and is for me one of its appeals.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh yes if you love police procedurals then you’ll enjoy this one but I have a limited enthusiasm for the subgenre, though I did enjoy Blood and Judgement more.
LikeLike
Ending threw me for a loop! I thought his best detection after Smallbone Deceased.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Oh I happily admit that the ending is a game changer, but I think because I hadn’t been able to click with the book in terms of setting, writing style and characters, I missed out a lot in the impact.
LikeLike
haha equally I am one of those rare people who did not enjoy smallbone deceased…
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am a huge fan of SMALLBONE DECEASED, in fact it was my first Gilbert book and led me to a bunch of others. I’ll give this one a try though like most of Gilbert’s readers, I probably enjoy his earlier books more.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah I can see this book appealing to a lot of people I know (just wish I was one of them!).
LikeLike
[…] in a small Village: Death of a Favourite Girl (1980) by Michael […]
LikeLike
[…] My experience of reading Michael Gilbert has shown his work to be uneven. I either tend to really love them such as Death in Captivity (1952) or I struggle to engage with them such as this one or Death of a Favourite Girl (1980). […]
LikeLike