Source: Review Copy (Coachwhip)
Whilst Agatha Christie put her pharmaceutical experience to good use in her mysteries and Dorothy L Sayers used her career in advertising for one of her novels’ setting, it can equally be said that Tyline Perry (1897-1978) in her debut novel used regional experiences where she lived, to construct her fiendish mystery. During the time she spent in Colorado there were many coal mining fatalities brought on by incidences such as explosions and roof collapses. The devastation these occasions brought often produced workplace tension between workers and mine owners and all of this is brought to life in the opening chapter of The Owner Lies Dead (1930). As first chapters go this one definitely ranks with the best of them. An explosion has occurred within what the locals call the Haunted Mine, owned by Matthew North. Twelve hours into the rescue and things are looking far from good. Some miners have been retrieved, not all of them alive and conditions down below are making further rescue attempts too hazardous. Yet North’s eldest nephew, Tony, is not prepared to rest until the remaining miners have been found and he descends alone once more. Time passes and the worst is feared and no money will persuade anyone to go down there. Five weeks later the mine is safe enough to enter again and Tony’s body is found. Yet the first chapter closes with this tantalising information: Tony was killed by a bullet, shot from behind. No one went in after him and the miners he was going to rescue were already dead by this point. So who did it?
The remainder of the novel is from Tony’s youngest sibling, Henry. The next chapters are episodic in nature covering their childhood up to recent times. All of these episodes build up a picture of what Tony and his brothers were like, (the remaining brother being Rush). They also show the blossoming romance of Tony and their neighbour Regina and also how it disintegrates. There is the rising threat of Patrick Brace, who is determined to wreck vengeance on Tony and his family, believing Tony’s uncle swindled his father over ownership of the mine. His revenge seems nearly achieved when he weds Regina. Whilst in a Victorian novel these chapters would probably take up a large proportion of the book, Perry keeps them in check and chronologically the story soon reaches the few days prior to the mine explosion. There is also plenty of romantic jealousy, threats and even stolen money thrown into the mix.
The story charts Henry’s progress as he tries to unravel what has happened, as soon after the explosion various incidences and pieces of evidence lead him and his brother to believe not all is what it seems. But what has taken place? This uncertainty leads to both brothers suppressing what they know, wondering if the truth will hurt and scandalise those they love dearly and in Henry’s case wondering how much he can trust Rush, as his behaviour is far from unsuspicious.
What made this such a good read is the way it balances being a character driven story with also being a story with quite an intricate central mystery to solve. The tables are often turned on the reader as new information comes to light and the reader is forced to reinterpret the evidence. The first chapter sets the readers up with a tantalising foreshadowing of events to come but when those events turn up for the second time the reader is already beginning to look at them differently due to the new information they have learnt on the way.
One of the biggest strengths of the novel is the way it gets you to care about the characters so quickly and you become invested in what happens to them very early on. Consequently when the story focuses on the how of the crime, the various technicalities, impossibilities and logistical issues are much more interesting because you have gotten to know the characters first. The final solution is definitely satisfying. The reader may pick up some ideas about the solution slightly ahead of it being revealed but with Perry’s writing style nothing seems certain. It does not surprise me that this book got such good reviews when it was originally published, (which can be found in Curtis Evans’ introduction), as reviewers often commented on Perry’s inventiveness and how she is able to make ‘something of a “locked room” or “impossible crime” situation out of a mine explosion.’ A reviewer for the Spectator said that the novel ‘boasted a superlative puzzle’ but was also a ‘first class thriller, which is also a novel full of human interest and sound psychology.’ When I read the word ‘thriller’ I was a little concerned, however having now read the book I find that it is not really a conventional thriller. It is more that Henry’s finding out of information is less structured and formal than it would in a more traditional detective story. Equally police detectives do not enter the story into quite late on, again something which could make it more thriller like.
I also feel I should mention another strength of Perry’s work, which is her writing style, as it has a real quality to it, creating mental pictures for the reader in a few simple words, such as describing some of the rescue workers remerging from the mine as, ‘three blackened figures, like strange goblins.’ Equally I loved how in her opening paragraph she almost pitches nature against human endeavour, showing how small it is in comparison to the surrounding landscape:
‘the hill rose gaunt and gloomy against the stars, dwarfing the crude buildings of the mine […] looked like a toy village […] the group of people, huddled about the mine shaft, seemed pitifully helpless, puny humans at grips with nature.’
For me Perry is a multi-talented writer in that her writing skills cover a broad range of areas.
It won’t surprise you to hear that I heartily recommend this book and I am only sorry that Perry only definitely wrote one more mystery novel, (mostly writing short stories for the pulps), called The Never Summer Mystery (1932). Her obituary claims she wrote a further two novels, but Curtis has not been able to determine if this is a truthful or not. So Perry leaves us with another intriguing mystery! This story is action packed, suitably puzzling and has characters you get readily engage with and all of this is set within the unusual setting of a mining community. What’s not to love?
Rating: 5/5
Are you like the second person to love this one in a week? All right, I’ll bite, especially since my TBR pile has shrunk to something like 60 books.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Not sure, who is the other person? And 60 books is a mere nothing compared to some peoples. Anyways it’s important to have lots of variety in your TBR pile.
LikeLike
[…] ← The Owner Lies Dead (1930) by Tyline Perry […]
LikeLike
This sounds absolutely wonderful, what a great set up! As it’s one of only two books (we know of so far!) is it hard to get hold of?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thankfully not that hard to get a hold of as coachwhip have just reprinted it, so you get a copy easily on their website, amazon or abe books etc. Though if you go on their website you’ll be able to see their full range of obscure mystery writers. Good quality books and they are usually started with an introduction, often by Curtis Evans.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s great, I haven’t spent much time on Coachwhip, will check it out.
LikeLike
Coachwhip is great – I’ve particularly enjoyed the Todd Downing reprints. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Great review! The first edition is incredibly rare, so it’s fortunate there’s a reprint!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Wow, a rare five-star rating! Looks like I need to save up and make some more Coachwhip purchases. I have my eye out for ‘Anonymous Footsteps’ by John O’Connor – will you be reviewing that soon? It should have been released about the same time as ‘Rumble Murders’.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Not heard of O’Connor or his novel before. But having googled him his book does sound awfully tempting to review. We’ll see… Though in a few books times I should be reviewing Vultures in the Sky.
LikeLike
Looking forward to another Downing review! 😀
LikeLike
Somehow I missed this when you posted it — an impossible shooting with wonderful writing and excellent characters?! Damn, I’m in. Need to get to some of these Coachwhip books, as they seem to be reprinting some doozys…
LikeLiked by 1 person
I know what’s not to love! The impossible shooting element is well done I think as you sort of figure it out by degrees and even then can’t be sure you’ve got it right until the end. Had a lot of success with coachwhip reads, so would definitely recommend you give them a try.
LikeLiked by 1 person
TC’s lukewarm response to The Hex Murder (the review of which brought me to this review) has perhaps bumped that down my TBB, and your enthusiasm for this has elevated it significantly. This will most likely be the first Coachwhip book I try; just need to work out when, now…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well fingers crossed you’ll like this as much as I did.
LikeLike
It seems that there is another novel by Tyline Perry titled The Talking Dead published in the magazine Excitement of March 1931 issue.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh that’s really cool. I wonder if it is one of the unknown novels mentioned in the obituary, as Curtis was only able to track down this book and one other by Perry.
LikeLike
[…] Perry – The Owner Lies Dead […]
LikeLike
[…] The Owner Lies Dead by Tyline Perry […]
LikeLike
[…] Kate @ CrossExaminingCrime: What made this such a good read is the way it balances being a character driven story with also being a story with quite an intricate central mystery to solve. The tables are often turned on the reader as new information comes to light and the reader is forced to reinterpret the evidence. The first chapter sets the readers up with a tantalising foreshadowing of events to come but when those events turn up for the second time the reader is already beginning to look at them differently due to the new information they have learnt on the way. […]
LikeLike
[…] Owner Lies Dead has been reviewed, among others, at Beneath the Stains of Time, Cross-Examining Crime, and The Invisible […]
LikeLike
[…] noting that ‘to be like ourselves is a miracle in a detective novel.’ He felt Tyline Perry’s The Owner Lies Dead manages […]
LikeLike
[…] in April 2017 Tyline Perry’s The Owner Lies Dead (1932) claimed first prize with its unusual mining setting. The initial set up of the crime […]
LikeLike