The Marlow Murder Club (2021) by Robert Thorogood

Today’s read is one of my occasional forays into modern crime fiction and it was only recently that I discovered how divisive a book it is among my crime reading friends. So I was curious as to where I would land on the spectrum.


‘Judith Potts is seventy-seven years old and blissfully happy. She lives on her own in a faded mansion just outside Marlow, there’s no man in her life to tell her what to do or how much whisky to drink, and to keep herself busy she sets crosswords for The Times newspaper. 

One evening, while out swimming in the Thames, Judith witnesses a brutal murder. The local police don’t believe her story, so she decides to investigate for herself, and is soon joined in her quest by Suzie, a salt-of-the-earth dog-walker, and Becks, the prim and proper wife of the local Vicar.

Together, they are the Marlow Murder Club.

When another body turns up, they realise they have a real-life serial killer on their hands. And the puzzle they set out to solve has become a trap from which they might never escape…’

Overall Thoughts

I have to admit this was a novel I particularly struggled to get into, and it took me a while to quite put my finger on why. There is no time wasted in this story, as murder occurs suddenly and without warning, within a matter of pages. I don’t ordinarily have a problem with this and in a way I didn’t have a problem with it now. Yet on the other hand it was part of the problem, confusing right? This is because the first 100 pages of this book deliver a very fast-tracked narrative, beginning with the first death and with the initial investigation. Everything seemed to be happening too quickly and too swiftly. The word offkey springs to mind and this sense of things not being quite right also made its presence felt within the characters themselves.

Let’s start with Judith. The author is continuing to mine the old people are hilarious rule breaking maverick trope, commencing with his protagonist being a regular skinny dipper, and is participating in this activity when she hears the gunshot. The way in which this element was conveyed to the reader seemed a bit overdone and too crude a touch, when a more subtle approach could have been adopted. I think in some ways this aspect was added simply to bring about the ending of the first chapter, which seeks to upend notions of cape wearing superheroes. But yes it all felt somewhat forced, and there were several occasions in the story when Judith’s actions did not ring true with her character, leading me to question the purpose of certain narrative events.

Another strand of the story which seemed forced was the choice of detecting sidekicks and the manner in which Judith meets them and gets them on board. Their stark differences in living and personality were composed of too many cliches for my liking. Although an interesting angle to the trio is the way the others become suspicious of Judith and her possible murky past. But even the anti-hero elements there are well worn.

However, after the first third the plot improves, and the case Judith is investigating widens out. I found myself getting more into the story, even if I couldn’t fully invest in the characters. The prose makes for a quick read, so even if it is 300+ pages, you can still comfortably read this in a matter of hours. The personalities of the victims and suspects provide an interesting level of ambiguity, and Judith experiences a steep learning curve at the denouement of the book. This is suitably dramatic, though I found the solution a bit disappointing as it occurred to me early on and I had dismissed it as I thought it too famous to still be used.

I am aware that the author produces scripts for Death in Paradise and playing the story through my head I can see how this would suit that medium. I am just not so sure it is equally compelling to read in book format.

Rating: 4/5


  1. I think I’ve already mentioned how unimpressed with the characters I was when I read this. They all had their “quirky” tropes going, yet somehow all seemed the same. As my blog (If I ever get further than the About page) will delve into!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yes I did find that I had not become attached to any of the characters and at the end didn’t have much of an urge to find out what happened to them next. However, in comparison to The Thursday Murder Club I felt the plotting was better and you know it had clues!!

      Liked by 1 person

      • Oh, darn. Just bought The Thursday Murder Club because some people I can usually trust recommended it, even though I had been resisting. Now, I’m sorry I didn’t resist longer!


  2. I am impressed and stunned by this simple sentence: “The prose makes for a quick read, so even if it is 300+ pages, you can still comfortably read this in a matter of hours.”

    That is an utter impossibility for me. I have never been able to read 300+ pages in “a matter of hours.” Not even when I *had to* while in college. I’m lucky if I can manage 100+ pages in a matter of hours. And now the mystery of how you manage to read so many books in a year is explained. You are three times as fast as me when reading any book.

    Liked by 1 person

    • ha well I can’t always read that quick. I also think with this book the font size is generous in comparison to the page size and there were quite wide margins. Anyways if I didn’t read as quick as I do, then my TBR pile would have taken over my entire house, and not just have its own shelf.


  3. Oh, I’ve a copy of this novel on my TBR pile, as I’ve immensely enjoyed the other Thorogood novels, and immensely enjoy Death in Paradise – currently watching the latest season on DVD. 🤩 Not having read this title, and only having read ‘Thursday Murder Club’, I wonder about the comparisons made between the two novels – I wonder if there are more parallels barring the similar titles? 🧐

    I see you gave both novels the same rating, but reflect different strengths and weaknesses in your reviews. If past reading history is anything to go by, I suspect I’d like Marlow more, over Thursday – and your reviews suggest to me that this is likely. 🤓

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yes I think Thorogood’s book is more likely to be your kind of read, as you know it has clues, which always helps! Also the sleuth’s activities more properly feed into the end solution, whilst in Osman’s book the vast majority of the investigation ultimately has no relevance to the ending.


  4. I’ve been seeing mixed reviews of this as well. Sad that the solution disappointed for I find that even if some elements don’t work out, if the solution gives one a sufficient surprise, one is willing to overlook the other things a little.

    I also realise I have in fact also been confusing this with the Thursday Murder Club. I have the second book of the latter on my TBR so let’s see how it turns out.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.