The Vet It Was That Died (1945) by Marguerite Silverman

Today’s read is from a new to me author, and I imagine it is new to many of my readers too. Marguerite Silverman (1914-2003) only wrote 3 mysteries, the other two being Who Should Have Died? (1948) and 9 Had No Alibi (1951). The only review I found of this title came from Steve who has reviewed many an obscure mystery novel at Mystery*File. Upon investigating Hubin’s Crime Fiction IV, Steve mentions that each of these mysteries contains Chief Inspector Christopher Adrian as the detective, though in today’s read he finds a sleuthing assistant in Helena Goodwin, who is a newly qualified vet. It is due to Steve and his own literary detective work that I further learnt that Silverman was a vet, which explains why she describes her milieu so well. On his blog Steve writes that:

‘Marguerite R Silverman, MRCVS, ACIS, graduated from the Royal Veterinary College in 1935 and spent some time in companion animal practice before the Second World War. She then changed career and developed a successful business in verbatim recording (before the invention of the tape recorder). In 1958, following a holiday visit to Israel during which she had been distressed by the scale of the animal suffering she had seen, she founded the Society for Animal Welfare in Israel. […] In 1986 she approached UFAW about the possibility of SAWI being taken under its wing […] She died peacefully at a nursing home, near her home in Catcott in Somerset, on Friday 5 December 2003, aged 89.’

As the title suggests it is indeed the vet, Reginald Thorpe, who is murdered, poisoned in fact, and unsurprisingly he is a very unlikeable individual. It is at his veterinary practice that Helena is working, and she is quick to realise that Reginald’s wife Christine is not to be outdone in the unpleasantness stakes either. However, one bright spot is their niece Carol, whose inheritance is controlled by her uncle until she is 21. There is also a downtrodden kennel maid called Dora, who is furious at the way her employer treats his patients. Within 24 hours of meeting the Thorpes, Helena describes them as being ‘just like something out of a Dickens book’ to her friend, Christopher Adrian and his wife. With such a detestable victim motives abound and alibis are thin on the ground, but it still takes quite a bit of sleuthing to unravel this mystery.

Photo of the author

Overall Thoughts

Given the writer’s experience as a vet, the life of a vet is well depicted here, reminding me of the James Herriot tales. Silverman is particularly good at highlighting the economic vulnerability of newly qualified vets, who have been training for years and struggling to make ends meet as a consequence. Jobs are thin on the ground, so it is easy to see why Helena does not throw in the towel with her employer straight away.  The vet milieu also works its way into one of the motives, which I found interesting and bogus patient calls are also put to good use by the guilty party. In addition, the discovery of how the victim was killed also occurs during a veterinary case, though the reader will perhaps not be so surprised by it as Helena and the Chief Inspector are.  The matter of fact attitude of Helena during this scene also might belie the author’s veterinary past.

We are also provided with a map on the first page.

Silverman is careful not to overdo Helena’s role as an amateur sleuth, making sure her character still fulfils her day job. Yet it is through her work that she comes across more information which she then passes on to Chief Inspector Adrian. Thankfully, she is not one of those protagonists who withhold vital information from the police. Nevertheless, the chief Inspector does not confide in Helena straight away, and patiently waits until her alibi has been proven first. Even then he is somewhat cool towards her offer to help: ‘You mean you’ll be a damn nuisance and probably make everything about ten times as muddled as it is already.’ This anxiety is ill-founded though in retrospect.

This is a quick and easy read, and Silverman offers an interesting array of motives to investigate and provides lots of other household intrigues to keep the plot ticking along nicely. I would be more than happy to read another by this writer, though tracking the other books down might not be so easy.

Rating: 4.25/5


  1. Given the rating you gave the book, I think you liked it a notch or two more than I did, but it certainly is an enjoyable one to read. I have not found out anything more about the author in the meantime, and have quite forgotten to keep looking for her other two books. I wonder if Helena continues as Adrian’s assistant in crime-solving. All in all, Silverman certainly qualifies as a forgotten author, but based on the one book we’ve both read, I think she’s a solid candidate for reprinting

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Back in 2012 in a letter Geoff Bradley’s CADS: Crime and Detective Stories I pointed out that ‘The Vet It Was That Died’ in 1945 had exactly the same plot as John Rhode’s ‘Death In Harley Street’ published a year later. Both novels depend on their victims being medical professionals, use an identical room lay-out, a similar method of administering their fatal poisons, and a similar back-story of abandonment and illegitimacy. About that time, according to Curtis Evans, Rhode had offered Christianna Brand the use of his plots: I wondered if Rhode had done the same thing with Silverman, with her being lucky enough to get into print first. Why might he have done so, why should he know Silverman? Perhaps because he did not write but dictated his books, and Silverman (who opened a office services business) might have been one of his audio-typists.

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.