I am not familiar enough with Quentin’s work to definitively type his writing, but I think today’s read is more of the psychological crime novel persuasion. The story opens with Jonathan Duluth, a chief partner in a publishing firm, funded by millionaire Ronald Sheldon. Jonathan is still dealing with his fractious relationship with his son, Bill, the pair of them both still suffering from the inexplicable suicide of their wife and mother respectively three years previously. Added into the mix is the return of Ronald, after a 6 month stay in Europe, bringing unexpectedly a new bride and his in-laws, all of whom are to live handsomely at the expense of Ronald. Jonathan is far from easy about this new arrangement – are the Lacey family on the make, with gold digging plans in mind? This is not a question to be answered until the end of the book. However it is a fatal mistake of Ronald’s to leave his new wife, who is much younger than him, in the library alone with Bill. It is not many weeks later when shots are fired and Jonathan is plunged into his worst nightmare. But can his amateur sleuthing brother, Peter, bring him out of it?
Overall Thoughts
If mystery fiction is all about the puzzle for you then this is not the book for you, as the sleuthing which leads to anything a) happens behind the scenes or b) happens in the moment of the solution being revealed, (a moment which begins with presenting the solution as a fait accompli before morphing into something slightly different). Upfront sleuthing by Jonathan invariably leads to the proverbial brick wall. The way this book holds your attention is through its characters, in particular Jonathan, who carries the whole story. It is his journey of learning to accept the past and to seeing those around him differently which mostly propels the plot. Quentin also does a good line in character reversal and providing the reader with the unexpected. The story is quite a moving one until the slightly cloying ending which was a little too trite for my tastes, but would work quite well for a film adaptation. The additional mystery is to do with Jean, Ronald’s new wife, who until the end you can’t decide whether she is duplicitous or not. The title makes her sound very important and in fairness to her, events are brought into being because of her presence. Yet for all that I found her a rather non-entity personality and somewhat in the background, compared to Jonathan.
In some ways this has been a bit of a lukewarm review, which might make my final rating slightly baffling, but Jonathan as a character is a huge reason behind this score as well as the writing style generally. This wasn’t an exceptional read, yet in comparison to some of my previous reads this month it was a good read for where I was at. Barely felt grinchy at all! I think I would try Quentin’s work again, so if anyone has any titles to recommend do let me know.
Rating: 4.25/5
I’ve never come across a dud Quentin: even his/their not-so-good ones are very enjoyable reads. That said, the only one I’ve read in recent years is The Man with Two Wives, which I enjoyed very much.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks for the recommendation
LikeLike
4.25??? This is one of the later Patrick Quentins, written solely by Hugh Wheeler, who was one half of the writing partnership that produced a lot of Golden Age style books under the names Q. Patrick and Jonathan Stagge. The earlier Patrick Quentins range in style from GAD fiction to comedy thrillers (‘Run to Death’) to straight thrillers (‘The Follower’). These Wheeler books are quite serious in tone (except for ‘Suspicious Circumstances’ which is fairly light and funny) and can be described as crime novels (as they were in the Gollancz editions) rather than guessing game potboilers. For me, as for Anthony Berkeley, they were the best things going in their day and I don’t think they’ve been bettered since. 4.25! I feel you misjudge the cleverness of the plotting here: Wheeler is trying to baffle the reader in these books and I think he achieves that admirably, yet when you look back at the story, it can be seen that everything fits together beautifully. As for recommendations, you might possibly prefer ‘The Man in the Net’ – a really brilliant and extremely tense piece of writing – but if you’re happier with GAD literature, then Q. Patrick’s ‘Death and the Maiden’ is particularly good.
LikeLiked by 1 person
We’ll probably have to agree to differ on the puzzle aspect of this book but thank for your recommendations. I’ve heard of TMITN, but not DATM. Both sound quite intriguing.
LikeLike
‘Death and the Maiden’ and ‘The Man with Two Wives’ (which I think is the best of the lot) are quite hard to find; ‘The Man in the Net’ might be easier to get hold of – though I believe there are plans to republish all the Quentin books soon.
LikeLike
Yes I think I remember reading something about that on Curtis Evans’ blog.
LikeLike
DATM is 1.99 on Kindle today. US Amazon.
Puzzle For Wantons too.
Even if you do not have a Kindle there are free Kindle apps for all devices.
I am reading S.S. murder. Very fun so far. 2.99 today …
LikeLike
Your description of this book is very enticing to me, since I am not so concerned about the puzzle. I have not tried anything by this author, but have heard things about him from various sources.
LikeLiked by 1 person
haha one more to add to the TBR pile lol
LikeLike
Death and the Maiden is my favourite (4.5/5), but I have only read about a quarter of the output by the authors. It is available as an ebook in the US.
LikeLiked by 1 person
DATM definitely seems to be a popular recommendation, as a few people have recommended it on FB as well. Will have to keep my eyes peeled for it!
LikeLike
Not quite sure how I’ve managed it, but I’ve found every book by Patrick Quentin, but only one by Jonathan Stagge and none at all by Q. Patrick. Does this reflect their relative rarity?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Good book hunting! It be due to relative rarity or perhaps just a case of being in the right time and at the right place for finding the books.
LikeLike
[…] are C. S. Forester’s The Pursued (2011), The Case with No Conclusion (1939) by Leo Bruce and The Wife of Patrick Sheldon (1954) by Patrick […]
LikeLike
This seems to be available as My Son, the Murderer
LikeLike
I just finished this a few days ago. Definitely a page turner. Much more murder melodrama than murder mystery.
There’s no reason for Peter Duluth to be in it really, except a commercial motive (one assumes).
I think your rating is about right.
Lots of PQ, QP in Kindle now. If you check periodically the prices sometimes drop at random. I picked up half a dozen at two bucks each.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Glad you enjoyed this one and look forward to hearing which of your new PQ acquisitions are good reads.
LikeLike
The only Puzzle so far is Puppets. It is like a comedy movie from the era with Myrna Loy or Irene Dunne: snappy dialogue, lots of fun. The plot eventually gets out of control a bit, and the solution is easy. Net result 4/5. I am assiduously collecting PQs now, with three good ones out of three so far.
LikeLike
That’s a very good run of strong reads.
LikeLike
I just read this book’s twin! https://thepassingtramp.blogspot.com/2014/06/kids-are-murder-my-son-murderer-1954-by.html?showComment=1545602244390#c2825656125989072045
LikeLike
This comment got spammed by the site. Sometimes links in comments cause this to happen.
LikeLike
Hmm.
LikeLike
Something up with comments.
I just read this book’s twin. Return to the Scene by Q. Patrick, 1940. It’s a rewrite of the earlier book!
LikeLike
Having read the first 6 Puzzles for books I was puzzled that Mr Duluth had a son aged 19 until I realised it wasn’t Peter narrating. Apart from how does Jonathan become shortened to Jake, I enjoyed the ride.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah Jake does not seem like a natural nickname for Jonathan. How puzzling!
LikeLike