Paul Temple and the Kelby Affair (1970) by Francis Durbridge

I got this novella free in my goodie bag at the Bodies from the Library conference and in need of a quick easy read I decided to give this one a go. It all begins with Scott Reed, who is a publisher and at the start of the book he is dashing to meet Alfred Kelby, a historian, as he plans on publishing Margaret Spender’s diary. Spender was the secret lover and secretary of Lord Delamore, who was also mysteriously murdered in 1947. Due to the diary being from within living history there are lots of people mentioned who are still alive, including Kelby. He gives Kelby the diary to read through and give his opinion on how accurate it is. Of course no one is surprised when Kelby is kidnapped at the end of Chapter 1, nor when he is later found dead, the diary missing. Paul Temple’s entry into the case as amateur sleuth is made through Scott who is also his publisher. The diary is not the only angle, as we also have a layabout older son and a debtor unable to pay up. As in keeping with other Durbridge stories further deaths follow, 5 according to my calculations, which is quite something within a 140 paged story.

Overall Thoughts

In terms of the mystery plot I would say Durbridge does a good job, not only of bringing the Temple mysteries up to the date with the time he was writing but also in providing a simple yet complicated mystery for the reader to follow. Scandal in high places seems far more in keeping with 1970s than missing submarine plans after all. 60s/70s fashion is nodded at various points, especially in regards to women and we even have the Temples using a Swedish egg chair in their home. There are still some pleasing older notes though such as this line: ‘Charlie climbed from the car muttering about literary bloody gentlemen and the gritty realism of police work’ and there is even a Freeman Wills Crofts reference. Then again Paul Temple was driving past Guilford.

Yet the narrative becomes increasingly troubling, with someone high up in government circles acting in a very questionable manner, given the way various people decide to commit suicide after meeting with them, one of which the reader distressingly experiences first hand. The ethics of the police and Paul Temple, as well as their competence are severely undermined as the second half of the book progresses. Paul suffice to say is very careless with people’s lives and any modern police force would be on the carpet for the errors and unnecessary deaths that occur. Though at least one policeman decides to not drink drive…

One of my bugbears with the Temple series is his relationship with his wife, Steve, to the extent that I was quite surprised when I recently heard someone saying they really loved this aspect. Their marriage is definitely not an even one, with Paul requiring a lot of regular ego massaging and of course this would not be a Paul Temple mystery if Steve doesn’t go off and try to do something independently, for it to all end in failure and humiliation for herself.

On the whole I would say this mystery started well and the mystery plot structure is a good one, yet it is let down by the social world it is situated in, which drags it down, especially in the second half. However the pacing is faultless as ever, you definitely can’t say you don’t get your money or pages worth when it comes to action and dead bodies. So whilst this was not the world’s best read I am hopefully going to enjoy Durbridge more in my next encounter with his work, having recently procured some of the TV shows he created. I enjoyed A Game of Murder, which I saw a while ago, so hoping the same will happen again with the others.

Rating: 3.5/5

Just the Facts Ma’am (Silver Card): Academic

If you’re interested in finding out more about Durbridge and his considerable output in fiction, radio, theatre, TV and film, then check out Francis Durbridge: The Complete Guide (2018) by Melvyn Barnes.

Advertisements

5 comments

  1. Interesting idea about the plot being marred by the social setting, and of course the ‘men save the day from stupid women’ (which is a more obvious destroyer of plots). I am trying to think of more examples of where I have seen this happen. You have got me thinking!…

    Liked by 1 person

  2. After that interesting panel at BftLibrary, I too intend to read something by him – I did read some a long time ago, and just about remember the TV series. (I think my parents used to like them.) I will bear your thoughts in mind!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I’ve been listening to these as radio programs, which may change the experience — they’re great to accompany a long-distance road trip. I just listened to The Van Dyke Affair. It’s in the public domain; you can get it at archive.org. I think the actual voices of the radio actors are a good deal of why I enjoy these.
    The relationship between Steve and Paul Temple seems to me quite like a couple of other very similar relationships, like Mr. and Mrs. North, Jeff and Haila Troy, and Jean and Pat Abbott, where hubby is masterful and wifey is a little ditzy. (Our friend Jeffrey Marks is writing a book about that kind of detective couple.) Steve does go off and need to be rescued quite a bit, so I think you are spot on about that aspect.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yes I think I have come to the conclusion that radio/TV were the best format for the Temple adventures. Be interesting to read Jeffrey’s book, though reading about nit wit females may have to happen in small doses. Prats for wives is an aspect which does weaken a book for me, so much so I never got into the Abbott series. I’ve read a few more Norths and Troys but I am often left wishing that the females of the duos actually got to something productive other than make a fool of themselves. It’s why I so value the Delano Ames’ Brown novels – the power balance is much more effective there. What other couples in fiction would you say get it right?

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.