A Dying Fall (1955) by Henry Wade

This is the last of the Wade novels I got in a lucky charity shop find earlier this year and I am pleased to say that I am ending on a high note. The book opens with a horse racing event, the Royal Cup, and Captain Charles Rathlyn has bet his all on his horse, Silver Eagle, desperate for a win which will set him back up again financially. This is not to be though as his horse doesn’t win and faced with having to sell up, it seems more than fortuitous that Kate Waygold, the widower whose horse actually won the race, wants to employ him as her racing manager. Things look even better for him when marriage is on the cards. Yet marital bliss doesn’t last for long when Rathlyn falls in love with a younger woman and you can’t be surprised that the police are fairly suspicious when Mrs Rathlyn falls over the gallery balustrade one night. Rathlyn says she fell whilst sleep walking. But did she really? Yet to be fair to Rathlyn he is not the only suspect and the mystery becomes even more complexing when there is a second death.

Overall Thoughts

First off, Wade recreates the county racing set milieu really well and this is something which also comes up in the characterisation. As with many of Wade’s other novels we are given ambiguous central characters who we are not entirely are deserving of our sympathies. After all this book is littered with characters who are on the make one way or another. Then again the economical setting of the novel is rather bleak, portraying the county classes as struggling with post war taxation. In fact we get a rare cultural/political reference on the first page of this novel when Wade writes that:

‘The brightness of the early morning might have helped to this, but there was no doubt that a brighter and more hopeful spirit was in the air now that Winston was back in power again. Many people who had ‘given it all up,’ or were on the verge of doing so, now felt that life might be worth living, after all.’

I would also this is a mystery which is built upon its characters, seeing the direction their relationships are taking before the first death occurs. Wade definitely uses the second death in the story to great effect causing further mystification, as it would have been a poorer novel if the story had only the first death to contend with.

Whilst this is not a novel which radically changes the genre, it was superbly entertaining novel, doing what every good mystery novel should do. It also has, I must say, a killer last line.

Rating: 4.5/5

Vintage Mystery Scavenger Hunt Item (Silver Card): Any Other Animal

The Puzzle Doctor at In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel blog has also reviewed this book here.



      • Just that I could see only one interesting way for the story to end and Wade took it, rather than surprising me, making some of what went before it feeling somewhat superfluous.


        • I get what you mean but I didn’t react to it in the same way. The story didn’t feel like a waste or superfluous due to the last line. The text had to be the way it was to make the irony of that final line so potent (almost in Berkeley kind of fashion). Now in Lonely Magdalen by Wade there is a lot of plot which is superfluous.

          Liked by 1 person

  1. You beat me to this book! A Dying Fall is the only Wade title on my pile and excavated it only last week (after JJ’s review), but good to know it’s great one. I’ll safe it for a little longer.

    Liked by 1 person

    • haha its weird how often it happens, that just when you decide to read something, someone else does a blog review on it. Happened to me this week as well. Also love how you use the word excavate when it comes to your tbr pile. I am now sort of imagining some kind of Aladdin’s cave full of books.


  2. I have yet to read this one but I’ve been very impressed with Wade’s ability to create characters that are recognizable individuals rather than mere mannequins to be moved about as needed for the plot.

    Liked by 3 people

  3. Thanks for the review. I confess that my two forays into Wade haven’t been fully satisfactory from the standpoint of the mystery/ puzzle… Would you recommend me to include this title in my collection?

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.