Tuesday Night Bloggers: Crime in Costume Week 4

crime-in-costumeToday is the Tuesday Night Bloggers final look at costumes and disguises in crime fiction and what a month it has been! To catch up on the previous weeks’ posts click here:

Week 1

Week 2

Week 3

And here are this weeks’ posts:

Bev at My Readers’ Block: Tuesday Night Bloggers: Hallowe’en

Brad at Ah Sweet Mystery Blog: Curiouser and Curiouser: The Best Short Adventure of Ellery Queen

Helen Szamuely at Your Freedom and Ours: Tuesday Night Bloggers: Multiple Mask Murderers

JJ at The Invisible Event: The Tuesday Night Bloggers – Five to Try… But What’s the Theme?

Moira at Clothes in Books: Tuesday Night Club: Holmes and Costumes

For my own piece this week I decided to return to an author I haven’t read in a while, Edgar Allan Poe. Masques and carnivals crop up a lot in Poe’s short stories, such as in ‘The Cask of Amontillado’ (1846), ‘William Wilson’ (1839) and ‘The Masque of the Red Death’ (1842). In all of these stories the usual positive festival atmosphere is overturned and used as a vehicle for death – either as its own character or by human hand. Costume events are used as smoke screens and camouflage for dark deeds and even the choice of costume can induce paralysing fear on others. Additionally in William Wilson Poe uses characters in duplicate costumes to explore the conflict between self vs. alter ego.

Image result for the masque of the red death

However it is ‘The Masque of the Red Death,’ which I plan to look at in more detail, seeing it as the locked room/impossible crime mystery which Poe never wrote. The story is set in an unspecific medieval setting and Prince Prospero’s kingdom is being ravished by the Red Death, a plague decimating his population. However Prospero is far from concerned and instead invites his friends to one of his abbeys, which he then seals to prevent any ingress or egress, so they can have a permanent masquerade. Yet 6 months in to this party, at the stroke of midnight, a new fearful figure enters the proceedings, seemingly dressed as the Red Death. Infuriated the Prince pursues this new reveller only to mysteriously die. His friends come to his aid, only to find the red death costume untenanted and their own demises follow shortly afterwards.

Now it would be fair to say that despite an eventually very high body count, this story lacks a crime and any detection – we know who and why people have died, the allegory is fairly evident, with a clear message against ignoring those in need and the folly of trying to evade death. It would seem Poe, although credited as a grandfather of crime fiction, had different goals in this story. Yet it might just be me but when reading this story I was thinking what a great full length locked room/impossible crime novel this could be. The setting and atmosphere are engaging and the deaths macabre. The abbey is fitted so no one can get in or out, yet the new reveller disguised as the red death clearly suggests otherwise. This figure is also able to kill the less than likeable prince a few feet away from him and also manages to exit his costume before the prince’s friends come to his aid. Of course Poe has a more supernatural explanation for all of this, but what a task it would be to find a human based solution! I also think there would be extra tension if the prince’s friends did not die straight away, but one by one and if one of these guests could also be the sleuth, a sleuth who cannot call on outside help due to the plague rampaging outside the abbey and the fact the abbey is closed up. How to close such a mystery would also pose quite a conundrum.

So if you have any suggestions for a human based solution let me know or which favourite author you think could write such a book? (My money is on Paul Halter personally).


  1. Very interesting idea–posing “The Masque of the Red Death” as a locked room mystery. It’s a shame Carr isn’t still around to take up that challenge. It’s been a while since I read this–my memories are all over-laid with Vincent Price’s movie (which I like very much).

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Halter wrote a story in which a man is killed by a snowman which, upon inspection, turns out to just be a snowman, but the solution to that wouldn’t work here. But, yeah, of everyone currently writing impossibilities he’d be your man for this.

    Going back to the classics, it also brings to mind the impossible vanishing of the murderer when being closed in on all sides from Gaston Leroux’s The Mystery of the Yellow Room, and that’s a closer situation to this. Any and all other disappearances of this nature are eluding me at present…

    Liked by 1 person

    • Would be cool to know what solution Halter would give this setup. You’re right about the similarities to Leroux’s novel. Can’t remember how the killer leaves the room in that one. I also think this setup would work in a Jonathan Creek episode.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.