The Crime at Noah’s Ark (1931) by Molly Thynne

Source: Review Copy (Dean Street Press)

Vintage Mystery Scavenger Hunt Item: Christmas Tree

The Crime at the Noah's Ark

This is my second read by the recently reprinted Molly Thynne and unlike my own surroundings, of rare Northern English sunshine, the setting in this novel is decidedly snowy, to the extent that a number of people end up marooned in a remote inn, The Noah’s Ark. Angus Stuart, a writer who has recently published a bestseller, is the character through which the events of the book are filtered, though not written in the first person. He kindly assists two old ladies to the inn, sisters named Amy and Connie Adderley, the latter of which has an ear trumpet which leads to some mild comedy in the story. Other guests to the inn include the very dapper Felix Melnotte a professional dancer, Trevor an account’s clerk, Major Carew who becomes increasingly drunk, Lord Romsey and his grown up children Geoffrey, Victoria and Angela; the overdressed pseudo American Mrs Van Dolen who is bestudded with jewels, her secretary Miss Hamilton, Soames a commercial traveller and Mrs Orkney Cloude, a powerfully attractive woman who pales at the sight of one of the other guests. Of course there is also our amateur sleuth, Doctor Constantine, who arrives unnamed but who is easy to distinguish by his impressive head of hair.

Unusual events begin from the very first night, with Amy Adderley spying a masked man. There is also disquietude between the guests though principally aimed at the Major, whose drinking leads to him misbehaving around the female guests. It is not surprising when he is manhandled back to his room and locked in. Yet in the middle of the night guests are roused as a rope is seen by Dr Constantine hanging from the Major’s window. Has he attempted to escape? A search ensues which is hampered by the fact that the key to the Major’s room has gone missing. It is during this search that Mrs Van Doren announces that her emerald girdle has been stolen. When the Major’s room is finally broken in to the likelihood of him being the thief disappears, as he has been murdered in his bed with a blunt instrument. Now for many the case as it is would seem enough for anyone to sleuth, but Thynne ups the ante for her amateur and police detectives as it soon becomes apparent in the subsequent days there is more than one guilty party and they all seem intent on Mrs Van Doren’s emerald girdle. The problem is where has it got to? Thankfully Dr Constantine is there to unravel the mystery.

Overall Thoughts

In the first Thynne novel I read, Death in the Dentist’s Chair (1932) the crimes themselves were quite simple though the final solution was complex. In contrast in this novel the logistics involved in the crimes are the more complex and the motivations for them are simple. Thynne is good at depicting the group psychology engagingly and I think she handles her large cast of characters well, giving each one the right amount of attention. At one point in the narrative Thynne writes that ‘Stuart had the novelist’s trick of summing up and pigeon-holing people according to their various types…’ and in a way Thynne does do that a little with her own characters. But beware! Not everyone is what they seem. Her characters are well-drawn, though I feel Felix Melnotte is painted a little too stereotypically. At times I did wonder whether Doctor Constantine kept his ideas a little too much to himself, which is intimated in lines such as this: ‘but I must solve my chess problem in my own way, and though I’ve mastered one move, I’ve still got the others to deal with.’ However once the guilty parties are revealed (one of which is particularly satisfying, surprising and amusing), you can in retrospect see how you could have spotted it yourself, though it is perhaps not the easiest case to solve. Furthermore, near the end of the story, there is the issue of proving guilt as well, though this problem is soon solved. Yet I think the way it is solved, although understandable in terms of human behaviour, is perhaps not as satisfying for the reader. For those looking for a new seasonal mystery this winter, Thynne’s novel certainly fits the bill, with the atmospheric snow and burglar hunts aplenty most nights. It’ll make you glad you’re not going away this Christmas!

Rating: 4.25/5


  1. Thanks for the review. 🙂 I’ve just finished ‘Case of Sir Adam Braid’, and like ‘Crime at Noah’s Ark’ it presented a logistically complicated mystery. Part of the solution seemed to drop out as the procedural unfolded – as opposed to being pieced together as a puzzle, if you know what I mean – but there were one or two key strands that were foreshadowed/ clued properly.

    I think I shall try something showcasing Dr Constantine next. Am I right in supposing that ‘Death in the Dentist’s Chair’ boasts of a better puzzle than ‘Crime at the Noah’s Ark’?

    Liked by 2 people

    • I think you will prefer DITDC’s as the investigation is more linear and there are clear lines of investigation to follow, whereas with the TCANA’s due to the nature of the setting e.g. group of snow bound individuals, the plot can be more reactive than active. Looking forward to trying COSAB, as I haven’t tried a non-Doctor Constantine novel yet.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. […] There are several reasons for adhering to this rule. Snow is fun for small children eager to build snowmen or for adults to gaze at from indoors whilst holding hot drinks, but when it comes to travelling, it is simply a nightmare for all concerned. Aside from the risks of crashing your vehicle, which may be expensive to fix, there is then the additional dilemma of finding a nearby house to phone for help or stay for the night. The people at this property, if it is occupied, are complete strangers – how much can you trust them? And what chaos are you letting yourself in for? This was certainly the situation for Dylis Hughes in Another Little Christmas Murder (1947) by Lorna Nicholl Morgan and Inspector Parry in Maureen Sarsfield’s Murder at Beechlands (1948). Even an established inn or hotel cannot be presumed to be a trouble-free place, as the guests realised in Molly Thynne’s The Crime at Noah’s Ark (1931). […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.